STOCKTON – On November 26, 2018, a jury convicted Alvin Larry Davis, 78, of the July 5, 2012 rape and murder of Hazel Dingman, 84. Davis was charged with and convicted of:
- one count of murder with the special circumstance allegation of murder in the commission of rape by a foreign object;
- one count of sexual penetration with a foreign object;
- four special allegations regarding the rape;
- and, one allegation that the victim was over 65 years of age.
Davis was also charged with one prior “strike’’ - a 1964 robbery and kidnapping conviction.
“This was a very disturbing case that involved an elderly woman attacked and killed in her own home,” said California Statewide Law Enforcement Association (CSLEA) President Alan Barcelona. “The victim was murdered in 2012 and the killer wasn’t caught until 2016, until DNA technology advanced once again, and DOJ criminalists at the lab in Ripon identified Davis as a suspect.”
In 2012, Mrs. Dingman was discovered by her daughter in her residence, located on a three-acre wooded lot just west of l-5 in Stockton. Mrs. Dingman was bound with two pillow cases over her head. She had been raped with a foreign object and beaten to death.
The investigation by the Stockton Police Department and the California Department of Justice Bureau of Forensics Services in Ripon continued until early 2016, when updated methods in DNA analysis conclusively identified Davis’s DNA on multiple items found by investigators at the crime scene.
“This case is special because we used our new DNA interpretation software, which allows us to separate DNA mixtures of different people,” said John Miller, president of the Association of Criminalists, DOJ. “We were unable to separate certain mixtures before, and now we can with STRmix (pronounced Starmix), which employs something called probabilistic genotyping, and looks at many more factors in DNA mixtures than our previous method. This new software was used to identify the perpetrator in the case of Hazel’s murder from a mixture of DNA from different people. Technology keeps advancing, giving us wonderful new tools to help solve crimes.”
Davis was arrested in Las Vegas and extradited back to California to face charges filed by the San Joaquin County District Attorney’s Office. Davis, who had been in Stockton at the time of Mrs. Dingman’s death immediately left for Las Vegas until he was arrested for this crime.
Over the last several weeks, the DNA evidence along with other pieces of evidence and eyewitness testimony was presented to the jury, which resulted in the jury’s guilty verdict.
Davis will return to court on December 3, 2018 when a date for sentencing will be chosen. Davis faces a sentence of life in prison without the possibility of parole.